Why Did The Lynx Bench Their Starters Against The Fever? Minnesota’s Playoff Decision Explained

Cheryl Reeve
Cheryl Reeve

Minnesota Lynx coach Cheryl Reeve made one of the more unusual decisions of the closing days of the 2026 WNBA regular season when she effectively shut down most of her starting lineup during a game that could have clinched the No. 1 playoff seed.

With the Indiana Fever dominating Minnesota early, Reeve left Napheesa Collier, Kayla McBride, Courtney Williams and Natasha Howard on the bench for the second half of the Lynx’s 96-77 loss on September 22.

The move was not part of a pregame plan to concede the game. Reeve decided that once Minnesota fell far behind, keeping her most important players fresh and healthy for the playoffs was more valuable than asking them to expend additional energy chasing a comeback.

And despite losing the game, Minnesota wound up getting exactly what it wanted from the standings anyway: the Lynx clinched the No. 1 seed later that night when the Golden State Valkyries lost to the Portland Fire.

Why Did Cheryl Reeve Bench The Lynx Starters?

Reeve said the decision came down to rest, injury prevention and the rapidly approaching WNBA playoffs.

Indiana overwhelmed Minnesota at the beginning of the game. The Fever finished the first quarter ahead 31-16 and eventually stretched the lead to 57-28 during the first half. [WNBA]

Instead of asking her veterans to spend the rest of the night trying to erase such a large deficit, Reeve decided their legs would be more valuable when the postseason began on Sunday.

“It was apparent that maybe rest was a better option,” Reeve said after the game, explaining that she did not want her starters chasing a victory that appeared increasingly unlikely. [Minnesota Star Tribune]

Reeve also said that repeatedly chasing regular-season wins immediately before the playoffs could be counterproductive when the team was playing every other day. [Sports Illustrated]

How Badly Were The Lynx Losing When Reeve Made The Decision?

The game was getting away from Minnesota quickly.

Indiana closed the first quarter on a 14-2 run and took a 31-16 advantage. The Fever then opened a 20-point lead early in the second quarter and eventually went ahead by as many as 29 points. [AP]

Indiana led 57-34 at halftime.

Caitlin Clark ultimately finished with 27 points, nine assists and seven rebounds, while Kelsey Mitchell scored 20 and Aliyah Boston added 17. [WNBA]

Reeve had seen enough from Minnesota’s primary lineup and turned the game over to the reserves for roughly the final 25 minutes.

Which Lynx Starters Were Benched?

The four established starters who were effectively shut down were:

  • Napheesa Collier
  • Kayla McBride
  • Courtney Williams
  • Natasha Howard

Collier played only about 13 minutes, Howard and McBride approximately 12 each and Williams only nine. Maya Caldwell, who entered the starting lineup because Olivia Miles was unavailable, continued to see some playing time. [StatMuse]

The unusual minute totals made it clear that Minnesota had changed its objective from trying to win the game at all costs to protecting its key players for the postseason.

Was Olivia Miles Already Injured?

Yes, and that likely made Minnesota’s caution even easier to understand.

Rookie point guard Olivia Miles was a late scratch because of a left calf injury. Miles had recently broken Caitlin Clark’s WNBA single-season rookie scoring record, making her one of Minnesota’s most important offensive players entering the playoffs. [WNBA]

Reeve said she had almost held Miles out of Minnesota’s previous game against Connecticut and indicated that the team would evaluate her condition day by day. [AP]

With one important player already dealing with an injury, Reeve had additional incentive to avoid exposing Collier, McBride, Williams or Howard to unnecessary minutes in a game Minnesota was losing badly.

Didn’t Minnesota Still Need The Win For The No. 1 Seed?

Yes.

That is what made Reeve’s decision notable.

Entering the game, Minnesota could have clinched the No. 1 overall seed and home-court advantage throughout the playoffs by defeating Indiana. The Golden State Valkyries were still close enough in the standings to potentially catch the Lynx. [Minnesota Star Tribune]

But Reeve made clear that she considered playoff readiness more important than maximizing Minnesota’s chances of winning that particular game.

She said afterward that the Lynx were not going to obsess over playoff seeding and would accept wherever they ultimately landed. [Sports Illustrated]

In practical terms, Reeve was making a risk-reward calculation:

  • A comeback could have clinched the No. 1 seed immediately.
  • But Minnesota would have needed its starters to expend significant energy overcoming a huge deficit.
  • The playoffs were only days away.
  • One of Minnesota’s best players, Miles, was already dealing with a calf injury.
  • The Lynx could still obtain the No. 1 seed through other results.

Reeve chose the postseason health of her roster over aggressively pursuing the comeback.

Did The Lynx Clinch The No. 1 Seed Anyway?

Yes.

A few hours after Minnesota’s loss, the Golden State Valkyries lost 90-82 in overtime to the Portland Fire. That result clinched the No. 1 seed for Minnesota. [Minnesota Star Tribune]

The Lynx improved their playoff position without having to win the Fever game because Minnesota already owned the season-series tiebreaker against Golden State.

That means Minnesota will have home-court advantage throughout the 2026 WNBA playoffs.

Did The Lynx Bench Almost Come Back Against Indiana?

Surprisingly, yes.

Minnesota’s reserves dramatically changed the game after taking over.

The Lynx outscored Indiana 30-14 in the third quarter and cut what had been a 29-point deficit to just seven points, 71-64, entering the fourth. [WNBA]

Chloe Bibby led Minnesota with 15 points, hitting five three-pointers, while Liatu King added 12 points. Aari McDonald scored 10 and helped direct the reserve unit. [WNBA]

The comeback briefly raised an obvious question: Should Reeve have put her starters back into the game once the deficit became manageable?

She chose not to.

Indiana eventually regained control, extending its advantage again behind Clark, Mitchell and Boston before finishing with the 96-77 victory.

Why Didn’t Reeve Put The Starters Back In When The Lynx Got Within Seven?

Because doing so would have undermined the original purpose of sitting them.

Once Reeve decided that protecting her starters for the playoffs was the priority, sending them back onto the floor to chase the game after they had been sitting for an extended period would have created another workload and injury consideration.

Reeve instead treated the reserves’ comeback as useful developmental work. She said the extended minutes allowed Minnesota to learn more about how players such as King and Bibby could potentially be used. [WCCO]

That could matter in the postseason, when foul trouble, injuries or matchup changes sometimes force teams deeper into their rotations.

Was Minnesota Trying To Lose To Manipulate Its Playoff Matchup?

There is no public evidence that Reeve benched the starters specifically to manipulate which opponent Minnesota would face.

Reeve’s stated explanation was much simpler: the starters were performing poorly, Indiana had opened a huge lead, the playoffs were approaching and she believed conserving energy was preferable to chasing the game. [Sports Illustrated]

The Associated Press likewise reported that Reeve’s concern was avoiding additional injuries after Indiana’s fast start. [AP]

The decision certainly affected the playoff race because Indiana was still fighting for home-court advantage, but that is different from evidence that Minnesota deliberately attempted to engineer a particular postseason opponent.

Why Was The Game More Important To The Fever?

Indiana still had significant playoff positioning at stake.

The Fever entered the final week of the season fighting within a tightly packed group of teams for postseason seeding and still had a path to the No. 4 seed, which would provide first-round home-court advantage. [Axios]

Indiana’s victory kept those hopes alive.

That created a strange late-season situation: the Fever had strong incentive to keep pressing for the victory while Minnesota increasingly viewed getting through the night healthy as the more important goal.

What Did Napheesa Collier Say About The Lynx’s Performance?

Collier did not treat the early benching as an excuse for how Minnesota played.

She said the starters should be “disappointed and embarrassed” by the performance they produced before the reserves entered the game. [Minnesota Star Tribune]

The frustration was understandable. Minnesota’s starters were badly outplayed during the portion of the game in which both teams were using their primary rotations.

The Fever shot 53 percent overall and 42 percent from three-point range in the first half while Minnesota struggled to match Indiana’s energy and execution. [Minnesota Star Tribune]

The defeat was also Minnesota’s fourth loss in five games, adding another concern beyond the unusual substitution pattern.

What Does The Decision Mean For The Lynx-Fever Rematch?

Minnesota and Indiana play again Thursday, September 24, in the final game of the regular season.

The circumstances will be very different for the Lynx.

Because Minnesota has already clinched the No. 1 seed and home-court advantage throughout the playoffs, the result can no longer improve its postseason position. [WNBA]

That gives Reeve even more reason to manage the minutes of Collier, McBride, Williams and Howard and to remain cautious with Miles’ calf.

The primary goal for Minnesota now is entering Sunday’s postseason opener as healthy and rested as possible.

Why The Lynx Benched Their Starters: The Simple Explanation

Minnesota did not bench its stars because the September 22 game was completely meaningless.

The Lynx could have clinched the No. 1 seed by winning.

Instead, Indiana built such a large early advantage that Cheryl Reeve decided the potential reward of completing a comeback was no longer worth the physical cost of extending her starters.

With the playoffs beginning only days later and Olivia Miles already sidelined by a calf injury, Minnesota prioritized rest and health over one regular-season comeback attempt.

The gamble ultimately cost the Lynx nothing in the standings. Golden State lost later that evening, Minnesota clinched the No. 1 seed anyway, and Reeve got to save significant minutes on the legs of four of her most important players.

Lynx Starters Benched vs. Fever FAQ

Why did the Lynx bench their starters against the Fever?

Coach Cheryl Reeve decided that resting her key players before the playoffs was more valuable than asking them to chase a huge first-half deficit. Indiana led by as many as 29 points.

Did Napheesa Collier get injured?

No injury to Collier was reported from the game. She was held out primarily as part of Reeve’s decision to preserve the starters.

Was Olivia Miles injured?

Yes. Miles did not play because of a left calf injury and is being evaluated day to day.

Did Minnesota lose the No. 1 seed because it rested its starters?

No. Minnesota lost the game 96-77 but clinched the No. 1 seed later that night when Golden State lost to Portland.

Did the Lynx intentionally lose to avoid a particular playoff opponent?

There is no public evidence supporting that explanation. Reeve said the decision was about saving her starters’ legs, avoiding unnecessary injury risk and preparing for the playoffs.

How close did the Lynx reserves get?

Minnesota’s bench reduced a deficit that had reached 29 points to seven by the end of the third quarter before Indiana pulled away again.

When do the WNBA playoffs start?

The 2026 WNBA playoffs begin Sunday, September 27, giving Minnesota only a few days between the end of the regular season and its first postseason game.

Leave a Comment